message+method+art (tm)

Blog

Top Fortune 500 Logos Deconstructed

Published on by Matthew LaPointe in Graphics - Marketing

The logos of the top 100 companies on the 2010 Fortune 500 list are more alike than you might think at first glance. In this post I hope to uncover a few elements that are common, illuminate certain groupings, and hopefully help you think about your logo in the context of your brand a little differently.

Disclaimer: Before I get started I should point out each of the below logos was pulled in an effort to capture the most standard version of the logo each company uses. I’m sure a few are off, but for the purposes of discussing principles of logo design these will suffice.

2010 Fortune 100 company logos

While the logos of 2010's Fortune 100 may appear quite different at first glance, as we look a little closer a number of patterns emerge.

Logo design is mostly an art, but it is governed by practical rules that include proportion, scale, reproducibility, context, and other factors. Logo design also tends to reflect industry values. Consumer brands tend to have more stylized, iconic designs, whereas business-to-business or supply chain companies are less focused on this.

Proportions

There are typically three classes of proportion when it comes to logo design – a square, a tall rectangle, and a wide rectangle. Most people avoid tall rectangular logos because they are difficult to incorporate into a wide variety of design applications, though in some limited circumstances they can work well. How do the top Fortune 500 companies see it? The majority, about seven out of ten, have opted to use the wide rectangle. The remaining use square designs. None use a vertical design as a primary application.

Proportions of Fortune 100 company logos.

The proportions of most logos fall into three categories: square, horizontal rectangle, and vertical rectangle. Above is a rough breakdown of how 2010's Fortune 100 fit into these categories.

Color Choice

The graphs below speak fairly clearly for themselves: the Fortune 100 companies analyzed prefer blue (to include a few deep purples) followed by red and black. Of all the color choices three-fourths of the time one of those was chosen.

There are books written on the psychology of color discussing what emotion various hues evoke, but pressing on to the core of it this is what I think – blue is chosen because it is calming, and a preferred color by many. It is also lends itself well to various shades of itself. If you have a deep blue as your primary logo color you can use a 50% screen of the same and it works well.

This particular attribute cannot be said about the next most popular color, red. Screens of red are only used by a few, because a screen of red is pink. Red is chosen because it is bold and stands out well in signage. The sky is rarely red and often blue. Take a look at the companies that chose red as their primary color and think about the most important application for them, outdoor signage.

Black is chosen because it works well with just about any other color and is very clear. The most important aspect of a logo is to communicate your name. It is only art secondarily. I found it somewhat surprising how little green was used. I suspect that with the current green movement this will change over the coming years as new companies rise and old companies refresh their looks.

2010 Fortune 100 logos broken down by hue and color count.

The vast majority of the 2010 Fortune 100 companies' primary logos consist of 1 or 2 color designs. Three quarters include a shade of blue, red, and black.

Color Count

The perspective on color count couldn’t be clearer: don’t use more than one or two colors in your logo. A small number stray and use 3 (often a neutral such as black or gray is included in that) and the rest are clear outliers with 4 and 8 colors.

The reason for this is simple: cost and brand management. More colors cost more money to reproduce in many applications. I think the larger issue has to do with brands though. Most companies have multiple version of their logo, such as a monochrome version if their standard logo is two or three colors. But the more colors your logo has the more often you have to create style exceptions. The more colors a logo has the more difficult it is to include in designs because colors clash. When this happens designers often reach for an alternate (non-primary) version of the logo. Every time this occurs it is lost opportunity for brand reinforcement.

Logo Basics

Simple logos reproduce more consistently at small and large scales than intricate ones.

A few things to keep in mind when designing a logo:

  1. Basics: Keep it simple
  2. Color: Don’t use more than three colors
  3. Proportions: Consider a horizontal rectangular shape, else a square

The Fortune 100 companies shown above aren’t successful because of their logos. In fact, a few of the logos are downright awful. But, most of them realize that a strong logo is foundational to a strong brand.


Managing Brand Values

Published on by Matthew LaPointe in Marketing

Brands aren’t what you buy at the store. They aren’t logos or catchy jingles. The most successful brands are nothing more than ideas built on word associations which elicit controlled emotional responses. This isn’t to say that brands don’t offer value to consumers; it’s quite the opposite. Effective brands are able to relate to their customers needs and feelings. Understanding how to direct and communicate this type of controlled association is how strong brands are built.

Brand Values

There are a number of mechanisms marketers use to promote a brand. The first and most important is to clearly define brand values within your organization. Brand values are often expressed as a short list of words or phrases and may be accompanied by a short explanation describing the intent of each. This is the most important element in defining a brand because all other functions of brand equity are tied to these terms.

I don’t have special access to marketing strategy documents at Toyota Motor Corporation, but because their marketers are quite good at what they do we can guess at what brand values both their Toyota and Lexus brands are meant to embody.

Toyota / Lexus brand values

Toyota Motor Corporation works hard to control their Toyota and Lexus brands. When you think of Toyota and Lexus what words come to mind?

It is not by happenstance that these and other terms readily come to mind. Even though you have likely never read a list of Toyota’s brand values, it is likely you would have come up with a similar list. The question is how is this done?

Brand Promise

A company’s brand values translate into a brand promise for consumers. The brand promise is what a consumer believes a brand will do for them. The most direct ways to communicate the brand promise to your customers is through the following:

  1. Visuals. This includes your logo, but it is far from the only element. Products, presentations, proposals, and advertising must strictly follow a formal set of visual guidelines. These guidelines should be widely available and actively promoted within your organization.
  2. Words. A tagline may or may not be important for your organization, but regardless of whether you have one or not, words are flowing out of your organization continually. When reviewing all formal and informal communications it is important to consider the organization’s brand promise. This is especially critical in advertising, and other forms of self promotion or direct customer interaction. Developing a style guide that talks about how you talk about yourself is a good idea.
  3. Product. It stands to reason that if you don’t have a product that supports the advertised brand promise it will quickly fail. There are many brands that started strong with products that matched their advertised value propositions, but have struggled because over time a chasm developed between product and brand promise. In recent years we have seen this with BMW, Dell Computers, and others.

This isn’t all just smoke and mirrors. By defining your brand clearly you communicate firstly within your own organization what your values are. Gaining the loyalty of your employees builds buy in, which in turn translates to employees embracing and reinforcing brand values. Engineers understand clearly what is expected in terms of a product. Marketers understand how to promote it. And sales know how to sell it.

Consistency

The fundamentals of building a brand aren’t difficult to understand. What is difficult is consistent execution. Brand values must pervade an organization. Every image, every written word, every ad, and every web site should be directly influenced by defined brand values.